By Marlena De Lacroix a.k.a. Connie Passalacqua Hayman
Is it right or wrong for a daytime soap opera to kill off a baby or a child? After all, a large part of the viewing audience is young mothers, and they could find such a sequence unbearable to watch. After watching little Delia Abbott get hit by a car on Friday’s episode of The Young and the Restless, I’d likely vote it’s wrong to do such a storyline.
Killing off a child provides harrowing drama. But the problem with Friday’s episode was that it was so harrowing, it was thoroughly overwrought and over played. Everything was calculated to make the viewer feel pain.
Billy Abbott (Billy Miller) did what a parent should not do: he left his daughter Delia in the car when he went into a store to buy ice cream. She opened the door and chased her dog down the road when he hopped out. Then Adam (or perhaps it was Nikki, who was also out driving that night) came barreling down the road and hit her.
It took almost an entire episode for the ambulance to arrive, during which Billy, alone with his comatose daughter, ruminated over his mistake. These scenes were unbearable. Even worse were scenes in which we saw what Billy will likely miss — fantasy scenes of his daughter’s forthcoming (if she is still alive) graduation, wedding, childbirth and grown years in which Billy and daughter operated his restaurant as “Delia and Dad.”
In these treacly scenes (in which Dad kept saying “I love you” over and over) Delia was played by a series of older actresses . Miller soldiered on as an older and older Billy, although the actor was minimally aged. Each scene was engineered to evoke a tear. I’m sure many viewers couldn’t take the extreme melodrama of a tragically missed future and tuned out.
Meanwhile, Delia’s mother Chloe was shown at the movies, innocently making out with her ex-husband Kevin. On Monday, presumably Delia will die from her injuries.
This is not the first time a baby or a child was killed on a soap opera, but it’s certainly the most extreme. In the 1950s Lisa’s son Chucky was killed on As the World Turns when he was hit by a car.
In the most famous example of a child being killed, little Laura, daughter of Brooke and Tom, was hit by a drunken driver on All My Children. This storyline at least was done with the cooperation of the real Mothers Against Drunk Drivers (MADD) and was a critical hit. It said something powerful about drunk drivers.
But Delia’s accident and impending death so far has been pointless. All it did was create some excitement on a show that for so long has lacked much. That is if you could bear watching Friday’s episode. I breathed a huge sigh of real relief as soon as it was over.