By Marlena De Lacroix a.k.a. Connie Passalacqua Hayman
There she was in an evening dress with her beautiful blonde hair put up in a sophisticated bun, running through the streets of Monte Carlo. All of a sudden she was caught up into the arms of a strong, dark handsome man, and the two embraced in hard kiss.
Was it Grace Kelly and Cary Grant in the 1955 Alfred Hitchcock classic To Catch a Thief? No, it was Brooke Logan (Katherine Kelly Lang) running from and then being captured in the arms of Bill Spencer (Don Diamont) this week on The Bold and the Beautiful.
There was only one thing wrong with this beautiful footage on the classic soap. Instead of rooting for Brooke and Bill, we were generally rooting against them.Which is very strange for a soap. As we know, Bill is married to Katie (multi Emmy winner Heather Tom), Brooke’s sister, and has been caught cheating on her with Brooke in the past. Now, after Brooke miscarried Bill’s child, we were asked to root for the cheating couple again, as the betrayed Katie dissolved into tears once more in the living room of the Spencers’ Los Angeles mansion.
Was this new betrayal Katie’s fault? After all, Katie had set up a spying system of cameras and microphones in the same living room to catch her husband and sister together. Although they had acted innocently, Bill eventually found out about being spied upon and used his outrage as an excuse to pursue Brooke to Monte Carlo. Had Katie set herself up for misery yet again, by pushing Bill into Brooke’s arms? She’s done it before!
So, whose side are we supposed to be on? B&B is asking viewers to choose, and it’s a difficult choice. Yes, yes, the heart has its reasons and all that. But seriously, is adultery still wrong? We know it is, and so we root against Bill and Brooke. Yet, on the other hand, they are a handsome, sexy and strangely alluring couple. And yet, on the other other hand, we feel for poor Katie — always the victim, always awash in tears, betrayed by the two people she says she loves most in the world.
Is it right for a soap have a right to encourage fans root for what’s wrong? Some might say old fashioned moral judgments are just too, well, old fashioned for today’s for soap viewers. Or are they? Do you share Marlena’s queasiness about the glamorous Brooke and Bill romance? Do you feel sorry for Katie, or do you think she brings about her own misery? Do you think this is a good soap story, or one that is at heart a love triangle that is too morally confusing for comfort?